2009 Ourlads All-Rookie Team
Offensive Rookie-of-the-Year – Percy Harvin, WR, Minnesota
Defensive Rookie-of-the-Year – 3-way tie between Brian Cushing, OLB, Houston, James Laurinaitis, ILB, St. Louis, and Jairus Byrd, FS, Buffalo
| Pos. | Player | Team | Draft Round |
| Offense |
| QB | Matt Stafford |
Detroit Lions
| 1 |
| QB | Mark Sanchez |
New York Jets
| 1 |
| RB | Knowshon Moreno |
Denver Broncos
| 1 |
| RB | Beanie Wells |
Arizona Cardinals
| 1 |
| RB | LeSean McCoy |
Philadelphia Eagles
| 2 |
| RB | Donald Brown |
Indianapolis Colts
| 1 |
| RB | Shonn Greene |
New York Jets
| 3 |
| WR/RS | Percy Harvin |
Minnesota Vikings
| 1 |
| WR | Jeremy Maclin |
Philadelphia Eagles
| 1 |
| WR | Austin Collie |
Indianapolis Colts
| 4a |
| WR/RS | Johnny Knox |
Chicago Bears
| 5b |
| WR | Hakeem Nicks |
New York Giants
| 1 |
| WR | Mike Wallace |
Pittsburgh Steelers
| 3 |
| WR | Mohamed Massaquoi |
Cleveland Browns
| 2 |
| TE | Brandon Pettigrew |
Detroit Lions
| 1 |
| OL | Eric Wood |
Buffalo Bills
| 1b |
| OL | Alex Mack |
Cleveland Browns
| 1 |
| OL | Phil Loadholt |
Minnesota Vikings
| 2 |
| OL | Max Unger |
Seattle Seahawks
| 2 |
| OL | Eugene Monroe |
Jacksonville Jaguars
| 1 |
| OL | Eben Britton |
Jacksonville Jaguars
| 2 |
| OL | Michael Oher |
Baltimore Ravens
| 1 |
| RS | Bernard Scott |
Cincinnati Bengals
| 6b |
| RS | Sammy Stroughter |
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
| 7b |
| K | Ryan Succop |
Kansas City Chiefs
| 7 |
| Defense |
| DL | Brian Orakpo |
Washington Redskins
| 1 |
| DL | Terrance Knighton |
Jacksonville Jaguars
| 3a |
| DL | Roy Miller |
Tampa Bay Buccaneers
| 3 |
| DL | Sammy Lee Hill |
Detroit Lions
| 4 |
| DL | Tyson Jackson |
Kansas City Chiefs
| 1 |
| MLB | James Laurinaitis |
St. Louis Rams
| 2 |
| OLB | Brian Cushing |
Houston Texans
| 1 |
| OLB | Aaron Curry |
Seattle Seahawks
| 1 |
| OLB | Rey Maualuga |
Cincinnati Bengals
| 2 |
| OB | Clay Matthews |
Green Bay Packers
| 1 |
| OB | DeAndre Levy |
Detroit Lions
| 3a |
| FS | Louis Delmas |
Detroit Lions
| 2 |
| FS | Jairus Byrd |
Buffalo Bills
| 2a |
| SS | Al Afalava |
Chicago Bears
| 6 |
| DC | Jerraud Powers |
Indianapolis Colts
| 3 |
| DC | Bruce Johnson |
New York Giants
| FA |
| DC | Sean Smith |
Miami Dolphins
| 2 |
| DC | Jacob Lacey |
Indianapolis Colts
| FA |
| DC | Derek Cox |
Jacksonville Jaguars
| 3b |
| DC | Vontae Davis |
Miami Dolphins
| 1 |
| PT | Kevin Huber |
Cincinnati Bengals
| 5 |
| PT | Pat McAfee |
Indianapolis Colts
| 7a |
| PT | Thomas Morstead |
New Orleans Saints
| 5 |
| ST | Lardarius Webb |
Baltimore Ravens
| 3 |